| 1936 | William Moore | Guard | Associated Press |
| 1936 | William Moore | Guard | United Press International |
| 1968 | Dennis Nelson | Tackle | Associated Press, First Team |
| 1969 | Bill Bolinder | Tight End | Kodak, Second Team |
| 1971 | Larry Lokanc | Linebacker | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1972 | Ron Bell | Halfback | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1974 | Doug Simper | Def. Back | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1981 | Willie Boyd | Receiver | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1982 | Mike Prior | Def. Back | Kodak/AFCA, Second Team |
| 1983 | Clarence Collins | Receiver | Kodak/AFCA, Second Team |
| 1983 | Mark Marcinek | Tight End | Kodak/AFCA, Honorable Mention |
| 1983 | Paul Politi | Kicker | Kodak/AFCA, Third Team |
| 1983 | Mike Prior | Def. Back | Kodak/AFCA, Second Team |
| 1983 | Joe Spivak | Off. Line | Kodak/AFCA, Honorable Mention |
| 1984 | John Coppens | Quarterback | Kodak/AFCA, Honorable Mention |
| 1984 | Mark Marcinek | Tight End | Kodak/AFCA, Honorable Mention |
| 1984 | Jim Meyer | Off. Tackle | Kodak/AFCA, Honorable Mention |
| 1984 | Mike Prior | Def. Back | Kodak/AFCA, Second Team |
| 1985 | Mike Beneturski | Off. Guard | United Press Intl., Honorable Mention |
| 1985 | Bob Kampf | Def. Line | United Press Intl., Honorable Mention |
| 1985 | Jim Meyer | Off. Tackle | United Press Intl., First Team |
| 1985 | Paul Politi | Kicker | United Press Intl., Honorable Mention |
| 1985 | Jeff Smith | Def. Back | United Press Intl., Honorable Mention |
| 1985 | Dave Wilson | Receiver | United Press Intl., Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | Brian Gant | Linebacker | Football News, First Team |
| 1986 | Brian Gant | Linebacker | Associated Press, First Team |
| 1986 | John Kropke | Def. Line | Football News, Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | John Kropke | Def. Line | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | Paul Politi | Kicker | Football News, Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | Paul Politi | Kicker | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | Jeff Smith | Def. Back | Football News, Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | Jeff Smith | Def. Back | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1987 | John Kropke | Def. Line | Football News, Honorable Mention |
| 1987 | John Kropke | Def. Line | Associated Press, Honorable Mention |
| 1987 | Jeff Smith | Def. Back | Football News, Honorable Mention |
| 1987 | Jeff Smith | Def. Back | Associated Press, Second Team |
| 1988 | Mike McCabe | Punter | Kodak/AFCA, First Team |
| 1988 | Mike McCabe | Punter | Walter Camp, First Team |
| 1988 | Mike McCabe | Punter | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 1988 | Mike McCabe | Punter | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 1988 | Mike McCabe | Punter | Associated Press, First Team |
| 1992 | Toby Davis | RB | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 1992 | Toby Davis | RB | Associated Press, Second Team |
| 1992 | Toby Davis | RB | Football Gazette, Third Team |
| 1993 | Clint Cullen | Def. Line | The Sports Network, Honorable Mention |
| 1993 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | Kodak/AFCA, First Team |
| 1993 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | Associated Press, Second Team |
| 1993 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | USA Today/FB Gazette, Second Team |
| 1993 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | The Sports Network, H.M. ('93) |
| 1994 | Duane Butler | Def. Back | USA Today/FB Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1994 | Armandos Fisher | Def. End | USA Today/FB Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1994 | Armandos Fisher | Def. End | The Sports Network, Honorable Mention |
| 1994 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | USA Today/FB Gazette, Second Team |
| 1994 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | The Sports Network, Honorable Mention |
| 1994 | Andy Ziebarth | Off. Line | USA Today/FB Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1995 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | USA Today/FB Gazette, Third Team |
| 1995 | Todd Kurz | Kicker | The Sports Network, Third Team |
| 1996 | Eric Johnson | Def. Tackle | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1996 | Andy Ziebarth | Off. Line | Football Gazette, Third Team |
| 1996 | Andy Ziebarth | Off. Line | The Sports Network, Third Team |
| 1998 | Rickey Garrett | Receiver | Associated Press, Third Team |
| 1998 | Rickey Garrett | Receiver | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1998 | Rickey Garrett | Receiver | The Sports Network, Honorable Mention |
| 1998 | Kevin Glenn | QB | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1998 | Chad Pegues | Def. Tackle | Burger-King/AFCA, First Team |
| 1998 | Chad Pegues | Def. Tackle | Associated Press, Third Team |
| 1998 | Chad Pegues | Def. Tackle | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 1998 | Galen Scott | Linebacker | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 1998 | Galen Scott | Linebacker | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 1999 | Aveion Cason | K/P Returner | Football Gazette, Third Team |
| 1999 | Damian Gregory | Def. Line | Burger-King/AFCA, First Team |
| 1999 | Damian Gregory | Def. Line | Associated Press, First Team |
| 1999 | Damian Gregory | Def. Line | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 1999 | Damian Gregory | Def. Line | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 1999 | Damian Gregory | Def. Line | TeamLink.com, Third Team |
| 1999 | Mike Rodbro | Off. Line | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 1999 | Mike Rodbro | Off. Line | The Sports Network, Third Team |
| 1999 | Mike Rodbro | Off. Line | Associated Press, Third Team |
| 1999 | Mike Rodbro | Off. Line | TeamLink.com, Third Team |
| 1999 | Galen Scott | Linebacker | Football Gazette, Third Team |
| 1999 | Sam Young | Def. Back | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 1999 | Sam Young | Def. Back | The Sports Network, Third Team |
| 2000 | Dan Hama | Off. Line | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 2000 | Andy King | Off. Line | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 2000 | Galen Scott | Linebacker | Football Gazette, Third Team |
| 2000 | Jake Strader | Kicker | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 2000 | Ryan Szokola | Def. Back | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 2000 | Willie Watts | RB | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 2000 | Sam Young | Def. Back | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 2001 | Teddy Wulff | Center | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 2002 | Jonathan Friend | Def. End | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 2002 | Jonathan Friend | Def. End | Associated Press, Third Team |
| 2002 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 2002 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | Associated Press, Second Team |
| 2003 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 2003 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 2003 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | Associated Press, First Team |
| 2003 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | AFCA, First Team |
| 2003 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | CSTV I-AA Football, First Team |
| 2003 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | CollegeSportsReport.com, First Team |
| 2003 | Ray Robinson | Defensive End | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 2004 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | Walter Camp, First Team |
| 2004 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 2004 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | Associated Press, First Team |
| 2004 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | AFCA, First Team |
| 2004 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | CollegeSportsReport.com, First Team |
| 2004 | Boomer Grigsby | Linebacker | Football Gazette, Third Team |
| 2004 | Stafford Davis | Offensive Line | CollegeSportsReport.com, Third Team |
| 2004 | Ryan Hoffman | Punter | CollegeSportsReport.com, Second Team |
| 2005 | Stafford Davis | Center | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 2005 | Stafford Davis | Center | AFCA, First Team |
| 2005 | Stafford Davis | Center | Associated Press, First Team |
| 2005 | Stafford Davis | Center | CollegeSportsReport.com, Second Team |
| 2005 | Stafford Davis | Center | Football Gazette, Second Team |
| 2005 | Brent Hawkins | Defensive End | Walter Camp |
| 2005 | Brent Hawkins | Defensive End | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 2005 | Brent Hawkins | Defensive End | The Sports Xchange, First Team |
| 2005 | Brent Hawkins | Defensive End | Associated Press, First Team |
| 2005 | Brent Hawkins | Defensive End | CollegeSportsReport.com, First Team |
| 2005 | Brent Hawkins | Defensive End | Football Gazette, Honorable Mention |
| 2005 | Ryan Hoffman | Punter | The Sports Xchange, First Team |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | Walter Camp |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | The Sports Network, First Team |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | The Sports Xchange, Second Team |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | AFCA, First Team |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | Associated Press, First Team |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | CollegeSportsReport.com, First Team |
| 2005 | Laurent Robinson | Wide Receiver | Football Gazette, First Team |
| 2005 | Cameron Siskowic | Linebacker | The Sports Network, Second Team |
| 2005 | Cameron Siskowic | Linebacker | The Sports Xchange, First Team |
| 2005 | Cameron Siskowic | Linebacker | Associated Press, Third Team |
| 2005 | Cameron Siskowic | Linebacker | Football Gazette, Second Team |
