Scholar-Athlete of the Year
| 1993 | Carmen Hulit | Softball |
| 1994 | Jon McAvoy | Football |
| 1994 | Lisa Mihallik | Swimming |
| 1995 | Tim Achterberg | Football |
| 1995 | Mary Jane Johnson | W. Basketball |
| 1996 | Dan Muller | M. Basketball |
| 1996 | Mary Jane Johnson Owens | W. Basketball |
| 1997 | Dan Muller | M. Basketball |
| 1997 | Kristi Geary | Volleyball |
| 1998 | Jay Anderson | Baseball |
| 1998 | Michelle Kutcher | Volleyball |
| 1999 | Jay Anderson | Baseball |
| 1999 | Kress Shores | W. Tennis |
| 2000 | Adam Waugh | Football |
| 2000 | Andrea Lovelle | Swimming & Diving |
| 2001 | Adam Waugh | Football |
| 2001 | Stacia Beste | Track & Field |
| 2002 | Christian Goy | Track & Field |
| 2002 | Deborah Birrer | Swimming & Diving |
| 2003 | Josh Kauten | Baseball |
| 2003 | Abbie Scott | Softball |
| 2004 | Neil Plank | M. Basketball |
| 2004 | Liina Suurvarik | W. Tennis |
| 2005 | Steve Carrol | Football |
| 2005 | Kate Stake | Softball |
| 2006 | Jessie Janik | Volleyball |
| 2006 | Ryan Brown | Golf |
| 2007 | Shannon Nicholson | Softball |
| 2007 | Mike Vandello | M. Basketball |
| 2008 | Tracey Deyell | W. Swimming |
| 2008 | Kedric Meredith | Football |
| 2009 | Erin Lindsey | Volleyball |
| 2009 | Scott Krapf | Cross Country/Track & Field |
| 2010 | Scott Krapf | Cross Country/Track & Field |
| 2010 | Stacey Miller | W. Golf |
| 2011 | Scott Krapf | Cross Country/Track & Field |
| 2011 | Polly Hirt | Swimming & Diving |
|
